Magic Bullet vs NutriBullet – Which Is Right For Me?

Magic Bullet vs Nutribullet

Getting The Most From Your NutriBullet Blender

If you’re like many people, eating healthy is a big priority for you. One of the best ways to get adequate nutrition is through smoothies and protein shakes filled with healthy goodness.

A well-made personal blender like the NutriBullet blender is a great investment if you’re looking to eat healthy and you lead a busy life. You can put your ingredients in, pulse, remove the cup, and get out the door!

The two biggest competitors in this market of grab-and-go blending are NutriBullet and Magic Bullet, and both companies make fantastic devices. What makes one better than the other is definitely a matter of preference and needs, and hopefully, you will have a better ability to make a decision after reading this!

Features & Benefits

Both the Magic Bullet and NutriBullet are straight-forwardly designed blenders, capable of drinking out of the same cup in which you make your final product. This design is exceptional because of the convenience it provides, along with the ease of cleanup entailed.

The primary features of each blender are as follows:

NutriBullet

NutriBullet NBR-1201 12-Piece High-Speed Blender/Mixer System, Gray

 

  • 600 to 1700 watt motor, with up to 2.2 horsepower
  • Max blender capacity of 45 oz (that’s a HUGE smoothie!)
  • Multiple different cups included in the kit
  • Variable speeds, one-touch settings
  • BPA-free
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Capable of heating liquids

 

Magic Bullet Blender

Magic Bullet Blender, Small, Silver, 11 Piece Set

  • 250 watts, but only .335 horsepower
  • 16 oz blender capacity
  • 12 oz container and two 8oz containers included
  • BPA-free
  • Dishwasher-safe

Cleaning

Cleaning both the NutriBullet and the Magic Bullet is a dream. Since they are fairly standard, with no removable parts, you can conventionally clean them with ease. In addition, both systems are dishwasher-safe, and since they’re both smooth, round containers, they don’t have annoying nooks or crannies for food to get stuck within.

In addition, since both are BPA-free, there’s no worries about leaching of toxic chemicals from high heat into your food. The blades themselves are designed to be perfectly accessible to ensure ease-of-cleaning, and their stainless steel composition means they’re durable, even after repeated usage and high-heat cleaning.

Magic Bullet Blender Replacement Parts Cross Blade Cups Lids Gaskets Gear 14 Piece Set Compatible with Magic Bullet Blender Juicer Mixer 250W MB1001 Accessories

Downside problems

While both blenders are great at what they do, both have some downsides that may or may not affect your decision, but should be evaluated all the same. The Magic Bullet is great if you make mostly quick, fruity smoothies that require less fibrous vegetation and less ice. Tossing your ingredients in, pushing it down on the base, and letting it do its thing, and then being able to remove the container and get out the door makes for ultra-convenient breakfasts.

The NutriBullet, while similarly useful and convenient, is of course more powerful, if a bit more cumbersome. Both have shared difficulties, but let’s compare them.

NutriBullet Cup & Blade Replacement Set

Magic Bullet vs NutriBullet

In terms of one versus the other, there are a handful of differences that can be significant, honestly.

  • NutriBullet offers much larger blender capacity – 45oz versus Magic Bullet’s max 12oz container
  • Magic Bullet has no variable speed. In fact, it has no buttons at all; just push it down and blend. This can be a pro or con, but less control is often a con
  • The NutriBullet is significantly more powerful, with the lowest wattage being 350 watts higher than the max wattage of the Magic Bullet
  • The NutriBullet can pull off 32,000 RPMs, which means it can really handle much more fibrous food than the Magic Bullet

Related: Are Vitamix blenders Worth it

Cons of the Magic Bullet

  • The Magic Bullet, because its motor and wattage are lower, is not great for green smoothies or any other drink that includes of a lot of tough veggies or fruit
  • It cannot heat liquids, which means it’s not a great one-stop-shop for making soups
  • Smaller capacity can be a problem if you’re making something for several people (or even just 2)

Magic Bullet Blender, Small, Silver, 11 Piece Set

Cons of the NutriBullet

  • The NutriBullet system is more expensive by a wide margin than the Magic Bullet
  • While cleanup isn’t terrible, the NutriBullet can be more difficult to clean than the Magic Bullet
  • Blade problems are the number 1 negative review point on Amazon and Ebay

NutriBullet NBR-1201 12-Piece High-Speed Blender/Mixer System, Gray

One downside to BOTH products is their inability to handle large pieces of ice. Because of this, frozen smoothies or milkshakes can be difficult. It’s less of an issue with the NutriBullet, however, because of the larger containers providing more space for the ice to move around within.

Alternatives

Alternatives to the NutriBullet and Magic Bullet are widely varied, but consist of either off-brand “bullet” model machines like them, or larger-capacity, more “traditional” blenders like the Ninja or the Vitamix series.

The Vitamix can create large amounts of delicious smoothies or shakes with relative ease. It can handle the toughest ingredients, obliterating them into a cohesive, smooth mixture. The downsides are numerous, though – it costs significantly more than either the NutriBullet or the Magic Bullet. It’s also much larger, taking up more counter space and requiring more effort to clean and store.

Vitamix A2300 Ascent Series Blender

The Ninja is in the same vein as the Vitamix – it can handle almost anything you throw at it, from soups to frozen smoothies. The Ninja blender series offers significant power, like the Vitamix, but like the Vitamix, lacks the speed or the convenience of a bullet-type blender system. When you want a smoothie or shake quickly and want to take it to go, you cannot beat the NutriBullet or the Magic Bullet. Though they struggle with thicker, tougher concoctions, if you’re on the go, nothing will beat them for ease of use and access.

There is also the fact that the debate of Magic Bullet vs NutriBullet can come down to a view of their accessories.

The Magic Bullet accessories list is short, but absolutely fantastic. It includes a series of handled-mugs, lids, and variable cups (though they all run smallish, within the 8-12oz range). In addition, there are some blade upgrades that can increase the handling ability of the device when it comes to tougher foods.

The NutriBullet accessories are similar, offering a wide variety of blades to process different foods more efficiently, as well as various lids and cups for differing occasions. NutriBullet has a milling blade for spices, coffee, and nuts, as well as travel-lids and mugs.

Related: Best Vitamix blender for any budget

Conclusion

Determining the best smoothie blender is a struggle, but if you’re looking to make quick, convenient smoothies every day or at least several times a week, a bullet-style blender is probably your best bet. They offer quick, easy access to reasonable power, simple clean-up, and a blend-and-go ability that’s difficult to match with a traditional blender system.

If the decision comes down to a NutriBullet vs a Magic Bullet, the systems each have their own pros and cons. Magic Bullet is better for the occasional fruit smoothie or protein shake, when you’re late and need a quick meal. NutriBullet can handle repeated blending of tough, fibrous ingredients and is actually an ideal system for a raw vegan, or anyone who makes a lot of “green” smoothies. It is, however, a more expensive unit, and both are not great at dealing with ice, so making anything with an ice base can be more difficult.

In the end, both are great products, and it’s up to you to decide what is most important when looking at cost, efficiency, and durability, but hopefully, this information can help make that decision a lot easier!

Which Vitamix Blender Is Right For Me?

Best Vitamix Blenders

Why Vitamix?

If you’re into health and well-being, a fruit/veggie smoothie is probably something you’ve invested in a few times. Juicing is pretty popular currently, and a return to eating whole foods is something every health-conscious person should be keeping in mind at all times.

With that said, not many blenders can stand up to the rigors of all the healthy, good-for-you fruits, nuts, and vegetables you might want to include in your diet. The Vitamix doesn’t have that problem. Though their price point is a bit higher than many other blenders, they’re able to handle a broad range of ingredients, temperatures, and consistencies.

With that in mind, what’s the best Vitamix blender for the money? There are many models, and selecting the right one for you is absolutely critical in getting the best value.

Vitamix 5200 Blender, Professional-Grade, Self-Cleaning 64 oz. Container, Black

Features & Benefits

The Vitamix series of blenders, particularly the 5300 through 6500 models, are extremely durable. They boast 4.4 inch stainless steel blades that are rarely stymied by anything, from tough, fibrous veggies to thick fruit skins. Because of the extremely durable design of the blades, you won’t bog the machine down and burn out the motor on even the heartiest of soups and smoothies, and that’s a big deal. Many a blender has met its demise at the hands of an ambitious shake, or overly thick porridge.

In addition, the primary container of a Vitamix 5300 is squat but still able to handle 64oz of liquid. The short design makes it fit well on your counter, and also makes storing it a breeze. The powerful 2.2 horsepower motor will make short work of whatever ingredients you want to use, all while staying significantly quieter than similarly powerful blender motors.

In the question of the Vitamix 5300 vs 6500, the 5300 has a distinct advantage in that you can program the speed with dials set on the front of the machine. The 6500, while wonderful in its design and the forethought that went into it, only has programmable speeds, depending on what you’re making. While this is great for a one-click program, sometimes you want to control the speed of your blending between adding ingredients, and the 5300 allows for that.

For the most part, when you’re talking about the Vitamix 5300 vs 500, or any of the higher-ranged models, you’re looking at a price difference, along with more programmable settings (on the higher-end models). They’re going to be more pricey, but they allow for more one-click operation. Again, though, it may not be worth it if you don’t mind just using the dial for the speed. Ultimately, it’s a quality-of-life decision that doesn’t really affect the blender’s ability to create delicious smoothies, soups, and shakes.

Vitamix 5300 Low-Profile Blender, Professional-Grade, Self-Cleaning 64 oz. Container, Red (Certified Refurbished)

Cleaning

Cleaning a Vitamix, whether it’s a personal one or a larger, powerful model like the 750, is wonderfully easy. The machines break down into composite parts, and with their wide, squat design, there’s less space for food to get stuck. The problem with a lot of blenders is that they’re designed in such a way that cleaning them efficiently (and completely, to be honest) is a chore.

Vitamix blenders are incredibly durable; in fact, they handle hot soups exceptionally well, where other blenders will lose a gasket, crack, or leak when hot liquids are introduced. With this said, however, you cannot put the actual container itself in a dishwasher. The other removable parts are dishwasher-safe, but the main body itself, despite its incredible durability, will be compromised by the extreme heat of a dishwasher.

There is also something to be said about mineral build-up over time with a Vitamix. Because of how durable they are, often Vitamix blenders will be used for years on end, and all that use causes mineral build-up. This will make the container look cloudy, but it’s perfectly fine. If you don’t mind it, you can ignore it, but you will need some manner of mineral-cleaning solution to get rid of the cloudiness if it’s something that bothers you.

Vitamix 5200 Blender, Professional-Grade, Self-Cleaning 64 oz. Container, Black

Downside

Though a Vitamix blender is a wonderful investment if you often make smoothies, soups, blend up nuts, or milkshakes, it does have some downsides that should be taken into consideration.

The first and probably most noticeable thing is that a Vitamix is pretty costly, in the range of $300+. This is honestly the only major issue, as the durability and versatility of the machines themselves are hard to beat by most competitors. The primary downsides are between models and vary depending on your needs. This is how you’ll determine the best Vitamix blender for you.

Which Vitamix Is For You?

Vitamix 5300 vs 6500

The 5300, as we talked about, has the variable-speed controls, where the 6500 has pre-programmed settings. The 6500 is also more expensive, offering slightly more power but it might not be worth it for the additional cost.

Vitamix 5300 Low-Profile Blender, Professional-Grade, Self-Cleaning 64 oz. Container, Red (Certified Refurbished)

Vitamix 5300 vs 7500

These blenders are nearly identical, except for the motor. The 7500 has a newer motor that is slightly stronger and a bit quieter, but again, the 7500 is more expensive, and both models use the variable-speed knobs instead of programmed buttons.

Vitamix 7500 Low-Profile Blender, Professional-Grade, Self-Cleaning 64 oz. Container, Black

Vitamix 5300 vs 6300

The 6300 comes with more accessories, like a wet blade that’s better for thinner soups and drinks. In addition, it’s got a less powerful motor but more speed settings – it’s honestly going to come down to bells and whistles, and whether you feel the 6300 is worth more money for those bells and whistles.

Vitamix 6300: Featuring 3 Pre-Programmed Settings, Variable Speed Control, and Pulse Function . Includes Savor Recipes Book , DVD and Spatula. (PLATINUM)

Vitamix 500

This device is extremely powerful, compared to the 5300 and truthfully many other models of Vitamix. It can grind nuts and coffee, and has a beautiful metallic finish that is pretty eye-catching.

With that in mind, however, it’s a lot more pricey than the 5300, which does a fine job of almost anything you’d need it to, and unless you care about what your blender looks like sitting on your counter, you can probably forego the cost increase.

Vitamix Professional Series 500 Blender, Black

Bestseller No. 1
Vitamix E310 Explorian Blender, Professional-Grade, 48 oz. Container, Black
  • Variable Speed Control: Ten variable speeds allow you to refine every texture with culinary precision, from the smoothest purées to the heartiest soups
  • Pulse Feature: Layer coarse chops over smooth purées for heartier recipes, such as chunky salsas or thick vegetable soups.
  • The 48-ounce container is ideal for blending medium batches for small family meals. Cutting blades measuring 3-inch diameter to ensure a consistent blend every time. Electrical Ratings-120 V
  • Hardened Stainless-Steel Blades: Our aircraft-grade stainless steel blades are designed to handle the toughest ingredients, so from the first blend to the last, you get the same quality results. Cord length: 4.5 feet
  • Self-Cleaning: With a drop of dish soap and warm water, your Vitamix machine can clean itself in 30 to 60 seconds. What's in the Box: motor base, 48 oz. container, mini-tamper, cookbook
SaleBestseller No. 2
Vitamix 5200 Blender, Professional-Grade, 64 oz. Container, Black
  • Variable Speed Control: Easily adjust speed to achieve a variety of textures. The dial can be rotated at any point during the blend, so you're in complete control
  • Large Batches: The size and shape of the self-cleaning 64-ounce container is ideal for blending medium to large batches. Design Feature : Radial cooling fan and thermal protection system
  • Hot Soup: The blades in the Vitamix container reach speeds fast enough to create friction heat, bringing cold ingredients to steaming hot in about six minutes
  • Hardened Stainless-Steel Blades: Our aircraft-grade stainless steel blades are designed to handle the toughest ingredients, so from the first blend to the last, you get the same quality results
  • Self-Cleaning: With a drop of dish soap and warm water, your Vitamix machine can clean itself in 30 to 60 seconds. What's in the Box: motor base, 64 oz. container, getting started guide, DVD, classic tamper.HP: 2-peak
SaleBestseller No. 3
Vitamix Explorian Blender, Professional-Grade, 64 oz. Low-Profile Container, Black (Certified Refurbished)
  • Variable Speed Control: Ten variable speeds allow you to refine every texture with culinary precision, from the smoothest purées to the heartiest soups
  • Pulse Feature: Layer coarse chops over smooth purées for heartier recipes, such as chunky salsas or thick vegetable soups
  • Low-Profile 64-ounce Container: Perfect for family meals and entertaining, while fitting comfortably under most kitchen cabinets
  • Hardened Stainless-Steel Blades: Our aircraft-grade stainless steel blades are designed to handle the toughest ingredients, so from the first blend to the last, you get the same quality results
  • Self-Cleaning: With a drop of dish soap and warm water, your Vitamix machine can clean itself in 30 to 60 seconds. What's in the Box: motor base, 64 oz. container, tamper, cookbook
SaleBestseller No. 4
Vitamix A3500 Ascent Series Smart Blender, Professional-Grade, 64 oz. Low-Profile Container, Graphite
  • Program Settings: Five program settings (for Smoothies, Hot Soups, Dips & Spreads, Frozen Desserts, and Self-Cleaning) ensure walk-away convenience and consistent results. The A3500 pairs with the Vitamix Perfect Blend App: Unlock the Ascent Series A2300's full potential with 17 programs and 500+ recipes with the iOS + Android app.
  • Touchscreen Controls give the machine a sleek silhouette and are easily wiped clean.Electrical Ratings - 120 V, 50-60 Hz, 12 Amps. Cord: 4 feet
  • You're in Control: Variable Speed Control and Pulse feature let you manually fine-tune the texture of any recipe
  • Built-In Wireless Connectivity: The motor base is able to read the container size you've chosen and automatically adjust program settings and maximum blending times accordingly. Add a range of compatible container sizes, building a customized blending system designed to fit your needs.
  • Programmable Timer: A built-in timer helps avoid over- or under-processing your custom recipes. Set the timer to the length of your blend, and it will turn the machine off automatically. What's in the Box: motor base, low-profile 64 oz. container, low-profile classic tamper, Simply Blending Cookbook
SaleBestseller No. 5
Vitamix 7500 Blender, Professional-Grade, 64 oz. Low-Profile Container, Black
  • Variable Speed Control: Ten variable speeds allow you to refine every texture with culinary precision, from the smoothest purées to the heartiest soups
  • Pulse Feature: Layer coarse chops over smooth purées for heartier recipes, such as chunky salsas or thick vegetable soups. Electrical Ratings- 120 V, 50/60 Hz, 12 Amps
  • Low-Profile 64-ounce Container: Perfect for family meals and entertaining, while fitting comfortably under most kitchen cabinets. Cord: 6 feet
  • Hardened Stainless-Steel Blades: Our aircraft-grade stainless steel blades are designed to handle the toughest ingredients, so from the first blend to the last, you get the same quality results
  • Self-Cleaning: With a drop of dish soap and warm water, your Vitamix machine can clean itself in 30 to 60 seconds

Alternatives to Vitamix

There are other blenders out there for sure – Ninja, Nutribullet, and others all compete with Vitamix for the market, and they all have benefits and downsides.

Related: Buying a Vitamix blender – Are they worth the price?

Vitamix vs Ninja

The Ninja is another powerful blender, capable of handling just about anything you throw at it, but there are a few key differences between it and a Vitamix. The chiefest example is the price – a Vitamix is often significantly more expensive for a very similar machine, but that’s because they’re manufactured in the USA instead of overseas. That price carries a 7 year warranty and extreme durability, however, and the Vitamix, if taken care of properly, will last a very long time.

Nutri Ninja Auto-iQ Blender (BL482)

Vitamix vs Nutribullet

You’ve surely seen the Nutribullet, a quick-access personal blender that handles easily and puts out healthy food reliably. The Nutribullet is a great investment if you’re only making things for yourself, but ultimately the Vitamix will handle bigger projects the Nutribullet simply cannot. In addition, the Nutribullet isn’t as powerful as the Vitamix, meaning certain ingredients will be out of the realm of possibility for it to handle.

NutriBullet Pro - 13-Piece High-Speed Blender/Mixer System with Hardcover Recipe Book Included (900 Watts)

Conclusion

You can find Vitamix products on Amazon or at Costco for a great price, including Vitamix accessories and anything else you’d want to have with your blender system. Ideally, this information has helped you determine your needs and how different Vitamix blenders can handle them.

There’s honestly no one-size-fits-all Vitamix, but having a solid understanding of your needs should help you make a decision that will benefit you for years to come.

Related Post: Magic Bullet vs NutriBullet-Your personal preferences matter!